Field Notes / Drift

ORGANIZATIONAL BEHAVIOR, READ AS A SYSTEM

The news tells us what happened. The model asks why.

Commentary on management decisions, manufacturing systems, and organizational behavior through the lens of alignment, incentives, recurrence, and drift.

OBManagementManufacturing
MANUFACTURINGOctober 19, 20263 minute read

Retooling Without a Place for the People

When a plant retools for a new product, management holds a meeting. New equipment, new processes, new future. The presentation is full of timelines and throughput numbers.

What the presentation does not include is where the legacy employees fit.

Nobody says it out loud, but everyone on the floor is doing the same math: does this future have a place for me? When leadership does not answer that question, the floor answers it themselves. Rumors fill the vacuum. The best people start hedging. Some start job hunting quietly. The ones who stay are the ones who could not leave, and they bring their anxiety to work every day.

The issue is not that people resist change. The issue is that people cannot commit to a future they cannot see themselves in.

Then comes the second mistake: the tribal knowledge panic. Someone realizes the veteran operators are carrying the process in their heads, and suddenly there is an urgent project to document everything before it walks out the door.

But here is the part nobody says: much of that tribal knowledge is about to become useless. Twenty years of tricks for making a product you are no longer going to make. The setup shortcuts, the fixture tweaks, the undocumented corrections, they belonged to the old product. The retool makes them history.

What does not become useless is the feel. The troubleshooting instinct. The ability to hear when a machine is lying to you, to know which variable to check first, to tell the difference between a process problem and a people problem. Feel cannot be documented. It is not a procedure. It is twenty years of paying attention, and it transfers to any product you put in front of it.

And that is exactly what walks out the door when you do not tell people their place. Not the tricks. The judgment. The one asset the new process actually needs, because new equipment fails in new ways, and the people who can diagnose it fastest are the ones you just gave a reason to leave.

The fix is not complicated. Tell people where they stand. Bring the legacy operators into the new process design, because their diagnostic skill is the commissioning team you cannot hire. The machinist who spent years correcting a flawed process already knows how to find the flaws in the new one.

A retool without a place for the people is not a strategy. It is an announcement with casualties.

MANUFACTURINGOctober 19, 20262 minute read

Two years of watching a screw corrode.

Volkswagen first spotted corrosion on a steering-gear mounting screw in October 2024. It recalled 4.64 million vehicles in September 2026. Two years.

The issue is not the screw. The issue is the two years. For two years the company had the information and the defect had the vehicles. The investigation was running. The correction was not. That is my whole thesis in one sentence: tracking is not correcting. They tracked a steering defect for two years. Nobody corrected it.

I have worked in shops where a suspect part gets quarantined the same day. Not because anyone is a hero, but because the system is built to stop the line before it stops the customer. At VW, the system watched a corroding screw for two years and called it an investigation. An investigation that does not end in a correction is just a longer way of doing nothing.

No one was hurt, and that is luck, not management. If it can be observed, it can be measured. And if it can be measured for two years without being fixed, the problem was never the screw.

Source: VW Accused of Knowing Steering Defect For Two Years Before Global Recall, Osna.FM (citing Handelsblatt)

MANAGEMENTOctober 5, 20262 minute read

The layoff announcement that tells you nothing

I have watched a rumor of layoffs do more damage than the layoffs themselves. Nike, Meta, and Starbucks all announced cuts this week. Nobody knows who is going, where, or when.

The issue is not that companies cut jobs. The issue is that the people doing the work find out from the news, with no idea what the plan is. Leadership says "strategic realignment." Operators hear "am I safe on Monday?" That gap is drift, and it is measurable. The announcement rewards the stock price. The uncertainty is paid for by everyone else.

Source: The Wall Street Journal

MANUFACTURINGOctober 5, 20262 minute read

Nidec, or what happens when the numbers lie

Nidec's CEO resigned after the company found falsified testing and inspection data. Delayed results, a fallen CEO, and a CTO stepping in to clean it up.

The issue is not one resignation. The issue is that the numbers lied long enough that resignation was the only honest number left. This is masking: the dashboard was green while the product was not. Tracking is not correcting. They were tracking test results that were never real. A system that cannot trust its own measurements cannot correct anything.

Source: Morningstar / Dow Jones

MANAGEMENTOctober 5, 20262 minute read

They bought the software and skipped the hard part

A new survey says 51% of organizational leaders admit their recent technology investments failed to deliver. The reason is simple: employees kept working the old way.

The issue is not the technology. The issue is that nobody measured whether behavior changed. They installed the tool, declared victory, and never closed the loop. That is feedback lag. You do not fix drift by buying something. You fix it by checking whether the correction worked, and then checking again.

Source: Eagle Hill Consulting via PR Newswire

MANUFACTURINGOctober 5, 20262 minute read

Boeing's engineers just showed how correcting works

Boeing's 17,000 engineers and technical workers rejected the first contract offer. The company came back with a better one. They accepted it. No strike.

The system got a signal and adjusted. Rejection came in, the offer moved, alignment was restored. That is what operating inside the tolerance envelope looks like. I write about failures most weeks because failures are loud. This one deserves the same attention: feedback arrived, leadership responded, and the work goes on.

Source: Reuters

MANUFACTURINGOctober 3, 20262 minute read

Stellantis and the only test that matters

Stellantis is opening nearly 50 quality war rooms and putting thousands of engineers on its build-quality problems. Jeep sits at 267 problems per 100 vehicles. Ram at 216. The US average is 204.

The issue is not the war rooms. The issue is whether the same defects stop coming back.

Stellantis reports its internal quality tracking improved over 50 percent this year. That sentence is the problem. Tracking is not correcting. A better dashboard and the same defects means the system got better at watching the failure, not stopping it.

Watch one number: problems per 100 vehicles, quarter over quarter. If it falls and stays down, the correction held. That is the only test that matters.

Source: Autoblog, “Inside the 50 war rooms Stellantis is using to fix its quality problems”

ORGANIZATIONAL BEHAVIOROctober 3, 20263 minute read

BlackBerry died while the dashboards were green

BlackBerry didn't die when the iPhone launched. It died years earlier, while its sales were still climbing.

In 2011, BlackBerry posted record shipments. The dashboards were green. That same year, the PlayBook tablet launched without a native email client, three years after the Storm phone launched with a glitchy, lagging interface. Same mistake, same rush, nothing learned in between. That is what recurrence looks like.

The issue is not that BlackBerry missed the touchscreen. The issue is that the system kept rewarding the old behavior while the strategy pointed somewhere new. Engineers who optimized data compression and carrier relationships got the budgets and the promotions. Engineers who pushed for an app ecosystem got shut down. People learn the real priority from reinforcement, not the poster on the wall.

Leadership read the sales figures and called it alignment. The developers building keyboard variants for carriers knew the operating system couldn't compete. When the top and the floor disagree about reality, that is a coherence failure.

A drift reading in 2010 would have shown all three signals separating while revenue peaked. That is the point of measuring over time. Anyone can explain BlackBerry after the fact. The question is whether your system is telling itself the same kind of story right now.

Source: The Rise and Fall (and Rise Again?) of BlackBerry, Harvard Business School

ORGANIZATIONAL BEHAVIOROctober 3, 20263 minute read

SpaceX fails in public on purpose

SpaceX is the interesting case because it does the opposite of almost everything that killed BlackBerry.

At BlackBerry, failures got documented and repeated. At SpaceX, the failure mode changes every time. A seal fails on one flight, the seal is redesigned for the next. The mistakes don't stop. They stop being the same mistakes. That is what learning looks like in an error stream.

The issue is not that SpaceX never fails. The issue is what counts as a fix. In most companies, an action item closes when the report is filed. At SpaceX, it closes when the hardware behaves differently on the pad. Tracking is not correcting, and they built the whole company around that sentence.

But the framework cuts both ways. SpaceX's alignment runs through one person. When the CEO and the chief engineer are the same mind, the drift angle stays small by construction. That is coherence, and it is also fragility. The open question is the tolerance envelope. Failing fast works when the cost of failure is a prototype. It gets harder when the vehicle carries a crew and the regulator is watching.

SpaceX shows what an organization looks like when it measures learning instead of compliance. The question is whether the system survives its own success.

Source: What Starship's Reusability Actually Means for Manufacturing Disciplines, SixSigmaKaizen

Put the model to work.

Contact John Brand for information about a free Organizational Drift pilot program for your business.

Ask about the free pilot